Prof Thurman Extols Bhutan’s Concept Of Gross National Happiness For Governance

Email

"His Majesty The Fourth King came up with the brilliant concept of Gross National Happiness, which is going to conquer the political science world eventually," said the Professor.

(Source: Journey with Robert Thurman)

 

By Tshering Palden and Nima | Kuensel

“Constitutional monarchy is the best form of governance, even better than the one America has,” Professor Robert Thurman said at a talk on ‘Buddhism, Democracy and Dharma Rajas’ in Thimphu recently.

He cited principles from the legendary Buddhist King of India, Ashoka’s edict to support his statement.

Buddha did not change the idea of kingship completely during his time, while Ashoka who followed Buddha’s principles did, he said.

Buddha in a way changed it by refusing to be the king. Instead, he chose to be enlightened, which was a huge shock to the vedist society at that time.

By Ashoka’s time, he said, the Buddhist institutions were more powerful and Buddhist knowledge was more widespread in India.

Brief introduction to Professor Robert Thurman

The father of the famous actress, Uma Thurman, Professor Robert Tenzin Thurman is the first westerner to be ordained as a Tibetan Buddhist monk by His Holiness The Dalai Lama. He is the professor of Indo-Tibetan studies at Columbia University, USA.

 

Source: Men's Journal

 

He also co-founded the Tibet House (USA), a non-profit organisation dedicated to the preservation of Tibetan civilisation.

Professor Thurman was named one of Time magazine’s 25 most influential Americans and has been profiled by The New York Times and People Magazine.

More about the five Buddhist principles

The professor also mentioned that he has extracted five Buddhist principles from the edict that Ashoka had carved on rock.

The first principle is ‘transcendent individualism’ where the flourishing of an individual is what the society is for, rather than collectivist ideas like communist and an ancient type of collectivism.

“Luckily when they do flourish and learn the nature of things, they voluntarily became altruistic because when an individual learns about reality, they realise that their well-being is tied up with the well-being of others,” he said. 

“Then they do serve the collective but out of their own free will, out of their creativity.”

“This is a totally different picture than being coerced into something or having to work like slaves for some aristocratic elite of some kind,” he added.

‘Non-violence’ is the second principle. Since human life form is valuable as an evolutionary platform, then to take a human life or simply taking any kind of life is bad.

The third principle says that the purpose of life is education because every individual learns from birth until death and not just when they are in school. Their deepest purpose is to always learn because the human embodiment is made for learning.

 

Ashoka’s rock edicts.

Source: Laurus Guide

 

The fourth principle is socialism that is voluntary altruism for society.

The fifth principle is ‘constitutional democratism’. In the case of Ashoka, he was still an emperor but he made a big fuss on how his edicts should be available to all his citizens and was concerned that all of them have an equal opportunity to develop themselves.

Merits and pitfalls of a democratic system

He said that the democratic system that America has, is better than some systems but it is not the greatest system.

“I think democracy is the best form of government but there are different kinds of democracy and the question of the executive is very critical.”

The problem with a democracy without a strong executive, even the executive not requiring election in any direct sense is important because otherwise everybody in the parliamentary system is a danger, they are sort of for sale.

“This is what has happened to America. Checks and balances have failed to prevent an unfit person from becoming the president.”

He said that he begged the His Holiness the Dalai Lama not to abdicate. Like the queen of England, she does not go to the parliament or be party to legislation but stands for a morale principle and mediates certain excessive political party conflicts.

“That’s what your Dharma Raja does and that I think it is preferable.”

Prof Thurman also mentioned that it is not preferable for everyone to be elected. Therefore, mercantile power can subvert the larger well-being of the people.

While one can say that a bad or tyrannical king can threaten the individual, he said that this is true but more likely in history.

There were times an individual has been badly threatened when the aristocrats got too powerful in the absence of a central head or head lama who can quieten them.

“The reason why they are more oppressive to the people are that they fight with each other and they draft people into their army,” he said.

For instance, in Chinese history, the worst periods were when there were weak emperors and the best periods were when an emperor had risen through rebellion against the past corrupt dynasty and taken the individual people’s needs and interests seriously.

The principles of Ashoka were also supported by Nagarjuna who wrote the ‘Precious Rosary of Advice’. 

Professor Thurman emphasised the importance of the concept of Gross National Happiness

He said that the Bhutanese are lucky to have a Dharma Raja. His Majesty The Fourth King came up with the brilliant concept of Gross National Happiness, which is going to conquer the political science world eventually.

 

His Majesty the Fourth King Jigme Singye Wangchuck

Source: Satokans.club

 

“The concept magnified as a sociological and political principle with a ministry and all is brilliant,” he said.

“He came up with this concept which fulfills in modern context, Shakyamuni Buddha’s, Ashoka’s and Nagarjuna’s teachings.”

The concept of ‘Gross National Happiness’ means that individual happiness is the purpose of the nation because the country is not going to have national happiness if individuals are not happy.

“It means taking into consideration, how decisions affect not the bosses, not just some owners but how it effects individuals in the society, so it fulfills the idea of transcendent individualism.”

“The king is an exemplary individual and he sets the example for all individuals. Moreover, he is not for sale – that’s the key thing,” he said.

Professor Thurman also added that the King does not get a campaign donation to win an election like the president does and that he cannot be controlled by the merchants or the aristocrats completely.

“He represents the freedom of an individual and since the purpose of an individual is to be happy, those individuals who understand kingship will enjoy the happiness of the king.”

The problem with total democracy, like communism is that their key emotion is ‘jealousy’ and to ‘compete with the next guy’.

“So the ‘Dharma Rajas’ are not for sale either by aristocracies, corporate powers or money, which is what ruins American democracy,” he said.

“Actually a hundred and some years ago, when Bhutanese adopted the kingship model, it was actually extremely fortuitous because the people went back from or under the Zhabdrung lineage where a monk was ruling.”

Bhutan, he said, went back to a royal king who took responsibilities with some kind of defense because it encountered British invasion. This enabled Bhutan uniquely to survive as an independent culture, following the deep principles of a Buddhist society.

“You did it and kept it alive but you are under stress today,” he said.

Bhutanese face challenges from all directions to preserve the values of GNH and to show that there is a modern form of it that really works.

In order to thrive successfully, Bhutan can tap on the potential of its blessed natural environment. The lineage of Dharma Kings can also control any mercantile excesses expressed through a parliament.

“Tibet and Mongolia got destroyed in the 20th century because they were still in a lamacracy, which could not defend itself.  The two can learn from Bhutan,” he said. “You are the inspiration for that.”

 

This article first appeared in kuensel and has been edited for the Bhutan Times.

 


Related Posts

Delegates From California Hopes To Replicate Bhutan’s Gross...

Tandi Dorji of Tara Tours and Trek said that the delegation came to work out a way to replicate GNH in California.

Nov 21, 2018 17:09

Cultural Festival To Be Held In Thimphu To Celebrate Gross...

According to the press release, the GNHCB’s President, HRH Princess Kesang Choden Wangchuck and other officials would...

Nov 08, 2018 08:39

Month-long Gross National Happiness Advocacy Programme Seeks To...

The Gross National Happiness team plans to visit at least seven colleges and 12 schools across the country.

Aug 31, 2018 12:28

Bhutanese Youth Devised Gross National Happiness Projects At The...

About 30 students attended the workshop from seven colleges in Bhutan.

Jul 16, 2018 18:41

No Medals Won But Bhutan Was Recognised For Its Concept Of...

Stephen Wade said that in the Olympics results, there is a direct correlation between how much money a country spends...

Sep 20, 2018 17:10

Gross National Happiness of Business Assessment Tool Proposed

The proposed GNH tool is expected to systematically assess a business establishment’s effort to integrate GNH values...

Nov 08, 2017 13:48

Latest

News

Discover The Transformation Of Samtse On Bhutan’s 111th National Day Celebrations

“The most remote gewog is now connected with roads,” said Man Bir Gurung of Norgaygang.

Dec 17, 2018 20:07

Bhutan Enters ‘Preparatory Period’ Of Five Years To Graduate From Its Least Developed Countries Status

The 'preparatory period' will end on 13 December 2023.

Dec 17, 2018 09:58

Features

Endangered One-Horned Rhinoceros Spotted At Royal Manas National Park In Bhutan

The one-horned rhinoceros was captured multiple times in a camera trap set up for tracking tigers.

Dec 16, 2018 12:33

73 Year Old Non-Formal Education Instructor Wants To Continue Teaching In Bhutan's Remote Villages

At 73, Serchung is one of the oldest non-formal education (NFE) instructors in Bhutan today.

Dec 16, 2018 01:09

Sports

Japanese Volunteers Taught Football Skills To Some Young Monks And Hope to Reach Out To All Other Monastic Institutions In Bhutan

Held on World Children’s Day on 20 November, the programme was spearheaded by the Japan Overseas Cooperation Volunteers (JOCV).

Nov 24, 2018 06:06

Female Archer Dorji Dema Hopes To Inspire More Women To Take Up Archery In Bhutan

Dorji Dema, a mother of three is among the first women in Bhutan to play in an archery tournament.

Nov 05, 2018 08:11

Business

JICA’s Horticulture Projects Benefit Farmers In Eastern Bhutan

The Agriculture Research and Development Centre’s Deputy Chief Horticulture Officer, Sonam Gyeltshen said that according to an impact...

Dec 13, 2018 22:16

Bhutan Expects Record Low Inflation In 2018

The nine-month average inflation rate this year was recorded at 2.61 percent, the lowest figure since 2004.

Dec 09, 2018 11:47

Travel

Lhop Widows From Samtse, Bhutan Keep Their Culture Of ‘Duk Tsho Hang’ Alive

There is a thriving custom among the Lhops – women are not allowed to wear ornaments after their partners die.

Dec 08, 2018 22:08

Bhutan Received 71,417 International Visitors In 2017; Singapore, USA And Japan In Top 10 List

In 2017, Bhutan received 71,417 international visitors and the revenue earned was USD 79m, the highest arrival and revenue since 2012.

Dec 03, 2018 11:25

Lifestyle

‘The Raven Tells A Story’ – Book Dedicated To Bhutan’s 4th King Jigme Singye Wangchuck Launched

The book was written by Her Royal Highness Princess Sonam Dechan Wangchuck.

Dec 17, 2018 15:47

Bhutanese Who Has Worked In New York And Singapore, Sells Artisanal Bread Via Instagram

Jamsel Tshering Gyaltshen decided to choose a future in the food industry after graduating from the Culinary Institute of America in New...

Dec 16, 2018 07:45

Subscribe to our newsletter

Never miss out on new happenings and news stories!